Downtown Toronto’s first local theatrical performance with a cast made up entirely of local actors took place in 1820.
Frank’s Hotel stood facing Market Lane Park just north of Front between Jarvis and Church streets. Back then you entered the theatre using an outside staircase that was located approximately where today the household cleaning supply aisle of the Metro grocery store in Market Square offers up Borax and Brillo pads.
The first manager of Frank’s was a Mr. Talbot. His wife—Mrs. Talbot—was the first star of the Toronto stage with her most famous role being “Little Pickles” in a comedy of the same name.
None of the history books I’ve read mention their first names. Women who appeared on stage in the late 18th and early 19th century often had to use the prefix “Mrs.” rather than their first name so the audience would know that she was a “respectable” married women and had the permission of her husband to appear on stage.